Wood vs vinyl vs aluminum: which fence fits your Florida home?
A straight comparison from a Broward fence contractor who installs all three.
The right fence depends on what you need most: privacy, budget, low maintenance, pool safety or a modern look. Here is how the three most popular materials compare in South Florida's heat, humidity and storms.
| Wood | PVC vinyl | Aluminum | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lowest | Medium | Medium to high |
| Typical lifespan here | 10 to 15 years | 20+ years | Decades |
| Maintenance | Seal or stain every few years | Rinse occasionally | Rinse occasionally |
| Privacy | Full | Full | Picket: low. Durafence: full |
| Salt air | OK with good hardware | Good | Excellent |
| Best for | Budget privacy, natural look | HOA communities, privacy | Pools, waterfront, modern look |
Wood: warm look, lower price
Pressure-treated pine is the most affordable way to get a full privacy fence. Styles like horizontal, shadowbox and board-on-board look great. The trade-off is upkeep: in Florida, wood needs sealing to fight sun, rain and mildew. Wood fence installation.
PVC vinyl: privacy without painting
Vinyl never needs paint and will not rot, which is why most Broward HOAs approve it. White and tan are the common colors. It costs more than wood up front but less over time. Vinyl fence installation.
Aluminum and Durafence: built for the coast
Aluminum will not rust, so it is the go-to near the beach, canals and pools. Picket aluminum is the standard pool fence; Durafence adds full privacy with an aluminum frame built for high wind. Aluminum and pool fences.
Our quick recommendation
- Tight budget, want privacy: wood.
- HOA community, want no maintenance: PVC vinyl.
- Pool, waterfront or modern look: aluminum or Durafence.
- Security on a budget: chain-link.
Common questions
Which fence lasts longest in Florida?
Aluminum, followed by PVC vinyl. Both resist rot and humidity far better than wood.
Is vinyl fence worth it over wood?
If you plan to stay in the home, usually yes: no painting or sealing and a longer life.
Get your fence quote
Takes a minute. We answer the same day. Hablamos español.
Fences we install
Vinyl & PVC fencesAluminum & pool fencesWood fencesChain-link fencesFence repairGuides
Fence blogFence FAQ
Family-owned fence contractor in Broward County, FL.
1331 N 70th Way, Hollywood, FL 33024. Hablamos español.
Hours
Mon–Sat
8 AM–6 PM